NGS Style Manual‎ > ‎- I -‎ > ‎

island, islander

Capitalize only when part of a proper name:
            Tangier Island            Long Islander            Hawaiian Islands
            Tangier Islander        Sea Islander               Hawaiian Islander

Otherwise, use lowercase:
  island of Tangier
a Potomac River island
the island of Hawaii, the Big Island
Pacific islands, Pacific islanders
South Sea islands (literary term only)